×
0

[woocs txt_type="code"]


Account
  • Log yourself in
  • Create an account

Categories
  • Accessories (20)
  • Airbag Canisters (8)
  • Alpride E1 Airbags (15)
  • Avalanche Airbags (55)
  • Avalanche Probes (21)
  • Avalanche Safety Kit (101)
  • Avalanche Safety Kits and Packages (18)
  • Avalanche Shovels (19)
  • Avalanche Transceivers (17)
  • Dakine Backpacks (1)
  • Jetforce Airbags (14)
  • Mammut Airbags (4)
  • Ortovox Avabag (16)
  • Ortovox Backpacks (22)
  • Osprey E1 Airbags (2)
  • Personal Protection (11)
  • Recco (Advanced Rescue Technology) (5)
  • Sale (42)
  • SALE & CLEARANCE (42)
  • Scott Avalanche Airbags (7)
  • Ski Accesories & Tools (29)
  • Ski Backpacks (23)
  • Ski Clothing & Hard Goods (15)
  • Ski Clothing | Base-layers and Thermals (6)
  • Ski Gloves (1)
  • Ski Goggles (4)
  • Ski Helmets (4)
  • Terrawest Safety Equipment (27)
  • Uncategorized (1)

Bestsellers
  1. Recco Reflector
  2. Ortovox Cross Rider 22
  3. Ortovox Zoom Package
  4. TerraWest Core Shovel
  5. Ortovox Free Rider 24
  6. Ortovox 3+ Avalanche Package
  7. TerraWest Warm Winter Face Scarf, Neck Gaiter, Snood
  8. BCA DTS Tracker 2 Package
  9. Ortovox Zoom Plus Transceiver
  10. Ortovox Free Rider 16

Information
    • Delivery & Returns
    • VAT Exempt Shopping at Snowsafe
    • Snowsafe EU
    • Snowsafe USA
    • Privacy Notice
    • Conditions of Use
    • Discount Codes
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • Snowsafe Blog
    • Snowsafes Partners and Friends 
    • Become a Snowsafe Affiliate
    • Snowsafe Avalanche Safety Centre
      • Avalanche Basics
      • Avalanche Factors
      • Backcountry Planning
      • On the Slopes
      • Avalanche Accident
    • Sitemap

UK flag Online Since 2001
Online Chat Online Chat
Next Day Delivery Order Before 1pm, DPD Next Day Delivery
Snowsafe logo

Avalanche Safety Equipment and Backcountry Products

×

Avalanche Safety Equipment and Backcountry Products

Home  »  Uncategorized  »  Avalanche Equipment & Awareness  »  Electronic vs Canister Powered Airbags – Pros & Cons
  • Snowsafe, 5 Chapel Mews, BN3 1AR
  • Call 01273 737676
  • My Account
  • Checkout
Categories
Avalanche Airbags
  • Airbag Canisters (8)
  • Alpride E1 Airbags (15)
  • Jetforce Airbags (14)
  • Mammut Airbags (4)
  • Ortovox Avabag (16)
  • Osprey E1 Airbags (2)
  • Scott Avalanche Airbags (7)

Avalanche Safety Kit
  • Avalanche Probes (21)
  • Avalanche Safety Kits and Packages (18)
  • Avalanche Shovels (19)
  • Avalanche Transceivers (17)
  • Recco (Advanced Rescue Technology) (5)
  • Terrawest Safety Equipment (27)

Ski Accesories & Tools
  • Accessories (20)
  • Personal Protection (11)

Ski Backpacks
  • Dakine Backpacks (1)
  • Ortovox Backpacks (22)

Ski Clothing & Hard Goods
  • Ski Clothing | Base-layers and Thermals (6)
  • Ski Gloves (1)
  • Ski Goggles (4)
  • Ski Helmets (4)

Travel

Sale
  • SALE & CLEARANCE (42)

Uncategorized

Currencies
[woocs txt_type="code"]
Manufacturers
What's New?
Black Diamond Transfer 3 Shovel

Black Diamond Transfer 3 Shovel

Bestsellers
  1. Recco Reflector
  2. Ortovox Cross Rider 22
  3. Ortovox Zoom Package
  4. TerraWest Core Shovel
  5. Ortovox Free Rider 24
  6. Ortovox 3+ Avalanche Package
  7. TerraWest Warm Winter Face Scarf, Neck Gaiter, Snood
  8. BCA DTS Tracker 2 Package
  9. Ortovox Zoom Plus Transceiver
  10. Ortovox Free Rider 16
Ski Insurance
Information
    • Delivery & Returns
    • VAT Exempt Shopping at Snowsafe
    • Snowsafe EU
    • Snowsafe USA
    • Privacy Notice
    • Conditions of Use
    • Discount Codes
    • Contact Us
    • About Us
    • Snowsafe Blog
    • Snowsafes Partners and Friends 
    • Become a Snowsafe Affiliate
    • Snowsafe Avalanche Safety Centre
      • Avalanche Basics
      • Avalanche Factors
      • Backcountry Planning
      • On the Slopes
      • Avalanche Accident
    • Sitemap

Snowsafe Blog


Electronic vs Canister Powered Airbags – Pros & Cons

As you know, Avalanche Airbags Technology has moved on in the last 5 years and 90% of snowsafe customers now choose the supercapacitor Electonic airbags.

Electric and canister-powered avalanche airbags are now available on the market, both to protect you in the event of an avalanche and both working in fundamentally the same way. 

Airbags are used for two simple reasons:

  1. To bring you to the top of the surface, when an avalanche breaks out your airbag will allow you to skip across the top of the snow rather then getting buried. 
  2. To provide you with an air pocket under the snow if you do get buried. The more air, the lower the CO2 concentration around the mouth, and the longer the person can survive. 

Types of Airbag Technology

Electronic:

Alpride – Alpride E1 is a fully electronic avalanche airbag, its supercapacitor technology replace the traditional Li-ion battery and results in the lightest electronical device on the market. 

Airbags using Alpride:

  • Scott Backcountry Patrol E1 22 Kit
  • Scott Backcountry Patrol E1 30 Kit
  • Scott Backcountry Patrol E1 40 Kit
  • Black Diamond Jetforce Tour 26L 

Jetforce Technology  – The Jetforce Avalanche Airbags system is a state-of-the-art technology that inflates your Airbag electronically, meaning you can store more than a single use and use it repeatedly by simply re-inserting the deflated airbag into your pack.

Airbags using Jetforce Technology:

  • Black Diamond Jetforce Pro 10 Airbag

  • Black Diamond Jetforce Pro 25 Airbag

  • Black Diamond Jetforce Pro 35  Airbag

  • Black Diamond Pro 25 Split Jetforce Airbag
  • Pieps Jetforce BT 10 Airbag

  • Pieps Jetforce BT 25 Airbag

  • Pieps Jetforce BT 35 Airbag

Canister Powered:

Ortovox Avabag – Ortovox offer innovative airbag processing technology, the avabag systems are the lightest canister powered airbag system currently operative in the world, weighing in at only 640g. Ortovox offers a compact, effective and removable airbag unit system.

Airbags using Ortovox Avabag:

  • Ortovox Crossrider 18 Avabag 
  • Ortovox Freerider 20 S Avabag 
  • Ortovox Freerider 22 Avabag 
  • Ortovox Ascent 28 S Avabag 
  • Ortovox Ascent 38 S Avabag
  • Ortovox Ascent 40 Avabag

Mammut RAS – The Mammut RAS Removable Airbag System 3.0 is an avalanche airbag system based on a square, brightly-coloured airbag that deploys behind the wearer’s head within seconds.

The new system is safe and easy to use. It is even lighterand smaller than before and can be attached to all RAS Removable 3.0-compatible backpacks.

Airbags Using the RAS Airbag System:

Mammut Flip Removable Airbag 3.0 Kit 

Mammut Ride Removeable Airbag 3.0 Kit


What are the Pros and Cons of each airbag 

Electrical and canister-powered airbags have both pros and cons, snowsafe breakdown below: 

AIRBAG TYPEPROS CONS

Electronic 

Scott Airbags

Jetforce Airbags

 

 

Rapid Inflations, not relying on canister. 

No need to carry cartridges.

Each charge of the lithium-ion battery can provide enough energy for multiple inflations.

No Folding your airbag, simply stuff it back in the avy pack. 

Easy to use.

Because they are fan-powered, they can be heavy.

Canister Powered 

Ortovox Avabag

Mammut Airbags

Rapidly inflates and does not rely on a fan.

Low weight: some state-of-the-art canister-powered devices weigh around 2.6 kg.

The canister is not user refillable.

Not all ski resorts provide canister refilling facilities.

Folding your airbag to ensure that it inflates again.

 


What are the limitations of electronic airbags and canister powered airbags?

Electronic

While you can inflate electronic airbags multiple times using the high-powered fans, they do not inflate as quickly as their canister-powered counterparts.

The high-powered fans work well, but it takes 1 second longer then canister powered airbags. If you suspect an avalanche, it’s best to pull to trigger immediately instead of waiting for confirmation.

Canister Powered

While canister-powered airbags are light and fast to inflate, you can’t always replenish the canister. Some ski resorts have refill services, but many don’t, meaning that you’ll need to prepare in advance and take canisters with you. 

  • Inflated airbag - Front View - Night Blue - Ortovox Cross Rider 18 Avabag
    Inflated airbag – Front View – Night Blue – Ortovox Cross Rider 18 Avabag

Test Activations

If you get into an avalanche situation, your life depends on your airbag deploying. You would prefer it, therefore, if you could test whether it works ahead of time, just to make sure.

The advantage of electronic airbags is that you can test them as many times as you like to see whether they inflate or not, giving you peace of mind.

The same is not true for gas canisters unless you have more than one with you. Once you use a gas canister, it’s gone until you refill and refilling in resort is not easy. 

Some canister powered units offer a test activation service, the Ortovox Avabags are supplied with rearming tools where you screw this into the canister unit and pull your trigger to test if this is working, a small pop noice will indicate that the unit is working. 


Deflation

Once your airbag is deployed deflating the air can sometimes be a pain, almost like wrestling with your bag. The electronic airbags offer a easy deflation mode where the air is removed automatically.

With Canister powered airbags you have to hold a deflation button and compress the air out of your bag until its ready to fold back into your bag, This can sometimes be time consuming. 


Flying with Electronic vs canister powered 

You can fly with both electronic and canister-powered airbags. However, because the canisters contain compressed gases, you can’t bring them with you in your hand luggage. 

Traveling with electronic airbags is usually hassle-free, but canister-powered can be more of a pain because you have to put the canister in the hold. 

Some countries like USA , Canada , Japan will not allow you to bring in Airbag Canisters in full stop . 


Snowsafe Conclusion 

Since season 18/19 we have seen a huge shift in the market with 90% of snowsafe customers choosing the new supercapacitor electronic Alpride Airbags.

Ortovox airbags, Jetforce airbags, and Scott airbags, are designed to keep you alive in the event of an avalanche.

Both canister-powered and electronic airbags have both advantages and disadvantages. The type you choose, therefore, depends on your personal preferences.

If you would prefer something lightweight, then canister-powered is the way to go. If, however, you want convenience when you travel and to be able to test your airbag before you head out on the piste, then electric is better. 


Snowsafe Blogs:

It’s important to stay safe and have the correct training when skiing or snowboarding off-piste please check out further blogs below:

  • What is a Recco reflector and why should you always wear one?
  • Why do mountain rescue services set off controlled avalanches and how?
  • Snowsafe top 10 products for winter season 19/20 
  • Mountain rescue dogs in avalanche situations
  • Mountain Rescue Drones Saving skiers lives from avalanches
  • Why add a Recco Reflector to your protective ski helmet?

If you would like to feature a blog about your organisation or experience in the snow please feel free to contact us on info@snowsafe.co.uk or 01273 737676. We are happy to take guest blogs linking back to your website. 

Shopping Cart
0 items

Total - £0.00

Checkout
ABS Avalanche Airbag
More info
Alpride
More info
Arva
More info
BCA (Backcountry Access)
More info
Black Diamond
More info

Information

Delivery & Returns

Privacy Notice

Conditions of Use

Gift Vouchers and Discount Codes

Contact Us

About Us

Guaranteed next day delivery in the UK

Snowsafe.co.uk is part of Target Services limited. Registered number: 2961616
Registered address: Target Services Ltd, 5 Chapel Mews, Hove, Waterloo St, East Sussex, BN3 1AR